Please login or signup to manage and calibrate your staff.
We adopted the word 'Medjil' from Whadjuk Noongar language, which means ‘accurate’ as the name for the survey instrumentation calibration portal.
The Medjil portal was developed by Landgate (the Western Australian Land Information Authority) in collaboration with the Intergovernmental Committee on Surveying and Mapping (ICSM) jurisdictions.
The portal allows the calibration of the following:
The purpose of calibrating the EDM Instrumentation (EDMI) is to establish the legal traceability of a user's instrument to the national standard of length provided by the National Measurement Institute (NMI). This is accomplished by determining the Instrument Correction and its uncertainty through a survey procedure conducted at a certified EDM Baseline. The certification of EDM Baselines are maintained by individual States and Territories.
The certification (or calibration) of EDM baselines establishes updated (or improved) distances between their pillars. The calibration of an EDMI provides distance correction specific to that instrumentation which are to be applied to measurements taken using that instrumentation (eg. EDM and prism). EDM Baselines and EDMI calibration should be conducted on a regular basis. Check your legislative requirements in your State and Territory for compliance.
The Medjil portal provides tools and reports for Levelling Staff, EDM Baseline and EDMI calibration procedures. Please refer to the specific guides that provide field calibration instructions.
This document includes reference information, encompassing mathematical equations, procedures, algorithms, and computations utilized by the Medjil portal. The calibration procedures are based on the following resources:
The Draft Verifying Authorities (VA) Handbook 2001 is intended for use by verifying authorities which are appointed under the provisions of Regulation 73 of the National Measurement Regulations 1999 in accordance with the National Measurement Act 1960 to verify reference standards of measurements under the provisions of Regulation 13, 30 and 31. The determination of the a priori standard deviations and the analysis of uncertainties of EDM measurements are based on the general guidelines within this handbook, ISO standards and GUM.
In this manual 'uncertainty' means 'expanded uncertainty' specified at the 95% confidence level. Standard deviation or standard uncertainty is specified at 68% confidence level. Users have the flexibility to adopt or modify default uncertainties and associated traceability statements as required.
For information on Medjil development and contribution, please refer to the GitHub repository.
Since their introduction, the use of EDM Baseline has been the preferred calibration method for EDM instrumentation. There are three different EDM Baseline designs:
Each EDM Baseline design aims to achieve an equal distribution of measured distances between the shortest and longest lines without any repetitions. They also allow EDMI calibration, with or without known distances (certified baseline distances), except for the Hobart design, which requires the distances to be known beforehand. Most EDM baseline designs aim to accommodate a variety of EDM instrument unit lengths. A detailed explanation of baseline design concepts is beyond the scope of this manual. For comprehensive information on baseline design, please refer to the book 'Electronic Distance Measurement' by J.M. Rüeger.
The current version of Medjil requires baseline distances to be known for all types of baselines to perform EDMI calibration. This approach is crucial for ensuring distance traceability to the national standard. Therefore, EDM Baselines must first be calibrated using NMI-certified instrument to determine the certified distances before proceeding with EDMI calibration. An additional module could potentially be developed to enable EDMI calibration without known distances. However, it is important to note that such calibrations cannot be certified under the NMI Act, and the EDMI distances obtained in this manner are not legally traceable to the national standard. For Medjil development and contribution, please refer to the GitHubrepository.
Deriving two observation equations not only ensures that distances remain non-negative but also enhances the flexibility of the EDM Baseline survey:
Where:
Dij = Measured distance between pillars i and j (the observation)
xi = Distance from the first pillar to pillar 'i'. Distance corrected for the pillar offsets and reduced to baseline reference height
xj = Distance from the first pillar to pillar 'j'. Distance corrected for the pillar offsets and reduced to baseline reference height
zpc = Zero point correction (an additive constant of the certified EDMI)
Let's consider the following example baseline, comprising four pillars:
A set of linear observation equations can be formulated based on Eq. 2.1 and Eq. 2.2 as follows:
In matrix notation, the observation equations can be represented as D = AX:
Where:
Dij = Measured distance between pillars i and j (vector of the observations)
A = The design matrix
X = The certified distances and zpc (vector of the unknown output estimates)
This approach eliminates the need to provide approximate distances between pillars. In accordance with Section 6, the observations, along with their a-priori uncertainties (P), undergo a least squares adjustment to obtain the estimated certified distances dx, the zpc value, and the complete VCV matrix.
To calibrate an EDM baseline, a series of inter-pillar distance measurements (surveys) are necessary, which should include atmospheric observations of the conditions during the during measuring of each survey distance. Medjil mandates that all instrumentation used in the survey must be calibrated and possess a current certificate stating the uncertainty of the instrument readings and the calibration corrections that can be applied. The uncertainty of instrument readings plays a crucial role in propagating uncertainties for the inter-pillar distance survey.
The distance observations are assumed to be slope distances that have not been corrected for the height of instrument or height of targets. Applying atmospheric corrections by entering these into the instrument is optional but Medjil requires temperature, pressure and humidity for every distance measurement even if this has been entered into the instrument. These values are used for estimating the propagation of uncertainty as well as the optional applying of atmospheric corrections when no correction was applied by the instrument during the survey.
It is recommended each distance (bay) dij (where i = from_pillar; j = to_pillar) should be measured four times. However, Medjil allows the number of repeat measurements to vary between bays and between surveys. The pillar survey data is to be provided in an ASCII file and must contain the following column headings and fields:
When multiple sets of meterological instruments are specified for the pillar surveys, the additional column headings and fields are also required:
Refer to this sample dataset required for an EDM baseline calibration survey data format.
Baseline measurements must be performed in accordance with the ISO17123-4:2012 Optics and optical instruments – Field procedures for testing geodetic and surveying instruments – Part 4: Electro-optical distance meters (EDM measurements to reflectors).
The pillar offset survey determines the offset of each pillar from the alignment of the first (1) and last pillar (n). Medjil performs the required reduction of observations during the EDM Baseline calibration process. Distances observed from every pillar of the baseline can be included in the calculation of the pillar offset if the survey setup includes measurements to pillar 1 and pillar n.
For each pillar setup, an arbitrary set of coordinates (Ej, Nj) are calculated for all pillars observed according to the formula:
Where:
dij = horizontal distance (in metres) corrected for calibration parameters and atmospheric corrections between pillars i and j
Hzij = angular direction observed at pillar i to pillar j
[Ej,Nj] = set of arbitrary coordinates (Easting and Northing) of pillar j
Then the offset of pillar j is calculated according to:
Where:
dj = horizontal distance between pillars i and j
Aj = derived bearing using coordinates of pillars: E1,N1 and Ej,Nj
As the instrument moves between pillars, pillar 1 and pillar n are observed in each setup. This allows the orientation of all setups in the survey and computation of an offset for each pillar from every pillar setup that included observations to pillar 1 and pillar n. Medjil computes the average pillar offset and standard deviation redundancy of observations measured from multiple pillars. These are used for a-priori estimation of uncertainties and the reduction of EDM measured distances to the reference alignment and height. Table 5.4 demonstrates an example set of pillar offsets.
Pillar heights (Hj) are to be determined as orthometric heights (eg. AHD71) and provided with standard deviations. The standard deviations should preferably be derived from redundant observations. Pillar coordinates are required and used to determine the baseline location in order to derive geometric correction to the distances. Medjil uses an average latitude of the supplied pillar coordinates to calculate the geometric corrections of surveyed distances (see, Section 4.3 ).
Data for the height of pillars is to be provided in an ASCII file and must contain the following column headings and fields:
Refer to this sample dataset for the required data format.
It is recommended each distance (bay) dij (where i = from_pillar; j = to_pillar) should be measured four times. However, Medjil allows the number of repeat measurements to vary between bays and between surveys. The pillar survey data is to be provided in an ASCII file and must contain the following column headings and fields:
Refer to this sample dataset for the required data format.
There are three distinct systematic errors which may occur in EDM instruments. The calibration of an instrument on a certified baseline allows to determine the specific instrument - prism correction that can eliminate of the following errors:
All distances measured by a particular EDM instrument and reflector combination (EDMI) are subject to a constant error caused by the following factors:
This errors may vary with changes of reflector, or after jolts, or with different instrument mountings. Zpc is an algebraic constant applied directly to every measurement.
Scale Correction Factor is proportional to the length of the distance measured and is caused by:
The precision of an EDM instrument dependents on the precision of the internal phase measurements. Unwanted interference through electronic/optical cross talk or multi-path effects of the transmitted signal on to the received signal causes cyclic errors. The major form of the cyclic error is sinusoidal with a wavelength equal to the unit length of the instrument. The unit length is the scale on which the EDM instrument measures the distance and is derived from the fine measuring frequency. Unit length is equal to one half of the modulation wavelength.
Where:
IC = Instrument Correction
D = Distance
zpc = Zero Point Correction
scf = Scale Correction Factor (1:x)
U = Instrument Unit Length (m) - wavelength/2
1C, 2C, 3C and 4C = Cyclic (short periodic) parameters
By default Medjil estimates only zpc and scf. However, Medjil is also capable of solving for cyclic error parameters (1C,2C,3C,4C) which depend on wavelength cycle errors. Solving for cyclic error is optional as the ability to detect this error reliably depends on the baseline design. Aarau, Heerbrugg, and Hobart baseline designs are typically tailored for instruments with specific unit lengths. If the instrument calibration was done on a baseline not specifically designed for its unit length, or if the accuracy of cyclic errors are not suitable, the user should consider performing additional calibration on the "cyclic error" testline.
For every distance measured on a EDM baseline the following observation equation can be derived:
Where:
vi = Residual is the difference between certified distance and the adjusted observed distance
Di = Observed distance
The angular values (sin and cos values) are expressed in radians.
Further the n observation equations for all distances measured on a certified baseline can be expressed in a matrix form as
Where:
A weight matrix can also be determined for the observed distances as:
Where:
SD = a priori standard deviation of the measured distance D
Refer to Section 4 for the derivation of the uncertainties of a measured distance. The observations together with a-priori uncertainties (p) are least squares adjusted as per Section 6. Note the weight matrix has the option to be additionally scaled by a variance factor.
Medjil maintains an instrument register that catalogues all instruments used for calibrations. Instrument register belongs to an individual company. The registry includes the archive of calibration certificates for EDMI, Barometer, Thermometer and Hygrometer. If calibration corrections have not been applied to instrument readings, Medjil allows calibration corrections to be applied to the raw readings during the Medjil calibration.
Data from one or two meteorological instruments (e.g. two thermometers, two barometers) can be recorded and imported to Medjil. If a set of two instruments have been used along the observed distance (e.g. at the instrument and target locations) Medjil will compute and apply averaged values.
All meteorological instruments (thermometer, barometer, hygrometer) can reference calibration certificates to apply corrections to raw readings. These corrections are sourced from the most recent instrument calibration certificate current prior to the date of pillar survey. Calibration corrections are applied as zero point correction (zpc) to the raw meteorological instruments readings:
EDMI calibration corrections are sourced from the most recent instrument calibration certificate current prior to the date of baseline survey:
If the meteorological corrections have not been applied to EDMI readings prior to upload, atmospheric calibration corrections will be applied prior to calculating the first velocity correction.
Where:
K = First velocity correction in metres
P = Pressure in millibars/hectopascals
t = Dry temperature in degrees Celsius
d = Distance in metres
e = Partial water pressure in hectopascals
$$C = (N_{REF} – 1)10^6$$
nREF = Reference refractive index (Section 4.2.2)
$$D = (n_G – 1) 10^6 (273.15 / 1013.25)\ \ \ \ (Eq. 4.2)$$
nG = Group refractive index of atmosphere for standard conditions
Partial vapour pressure is derived from relative humidity:
Where:
e = Partial water vapour pressure in hectopascals
h = Relative humidity in percent
E = Saturation water vapour pressure (hPa) at the dry bulb temperature:
Where:
p = Atmospheric pressure in hectopascals
t = Dry temperature in degrees Celsius
The terms C and D as well as EDM type, Unit Length, Modulation Frequency, Carrier Wavelength and Refractive Index are instrument specific (manufacturers supplied). Recommended values for common instruments are provided in the EDM Specifications Lookup Table. This table has been populated with information from the following sources:
These parameters are assigned to the EDM model and are used for all instruments of that model associated with the company. The Manufacturers Uncertainty Constant, Manufacturers Parts Per Million Uncertainty and Manufacturers Uncertainty Coverage Factor are required fields. These are used by Medjil to perform the statistical test recommended in ISO 17123-4:2012 (see Section 7).
Medjil treats phase and pulse measuring instruments differently (first velocity correction is different) thus the pulse instruments must have mets applied before importing data to Medjil.
Solving for cyclic errors can be performed for both types of instruments and is an option when performing and EDMI Calibration.
When solving for cyclic errors, Medjil will use a t-student test for both the first and second order cyclic errors. If errors are statistically insignificant, the design matrix will be compiled for either six, four or two parameters.
The Unit Lenth is a required field. It is used when test for cyclic errors, plotting the Return Phase Angle of Observed Distances plot at the end of the EDMI Calibration report and for calculation of the manufacturers reference refractive index when it has not been supplied in this form (See Section 4.2.2).
The Frequency, Carrier Wavelength, Manufacturers Reference Refractive Index, C Term and D Term are optional fields. These are used for calculating the atmospheric corrections for instruments. However, Medjil will refuse to process raw data where the atmospheric corrections have not been applied prior to upload, if insufficient parameters are supplied to calculate the atmospheric corrections. The C Term and D Term are used to calculate the first velocity correction (See Section 4.2.1). If the C or D Term are not supplied, Medjil uses the carrier wavelength, frequency and Manufacturers Refractive index to calculate these terms.The Measurement Increments are a required field. Medjil will use this value for propagation of uncertainty when the pre-selected Uncertainty Budget requests instrument rounding is included from the Instrument Register Record – Uncertainty Budget Sources (See Section 5.2).
The reference refractive index (nREF) is instrument specific and it is preferred that the manufacturer supplied value is used rather than calculated as the rounding error of the calculated value can be significant. If the refractive index is not provided Medjil uses Unit Length, Carrier Wavelength and Modulation Frequency stored in the instrument register to calculate this value.
Where:
CO = Velocity of light in a vacuum = 299 792 458 m/s (SI definition)
λMOD = Carrier wavelength of the instrument
fMOD = Modulation frequency of the instrument
U = The half of λMOD , called the unit length of the instrument.
In electro-optical EDM, the refractive index is dependent on the wavelength of the visible or infrared radiation. Different frequencies have the same propagation velocity in a vacuum, but not in air because of the interference occurrence between the different frequencies. The signal resulting from the sum of all frequencies will have the so-called group velocity, which is always smaller than the phase velocities of its individual frequencies.
Resolution 3 from the International Association of Geodesy (IAG) in 1999 at its XXIIth General Assembly in Birmingham, made the following recommendations.
The following closed formulae relates to recommendation three for the computation of the group refractive index in air for electronic distance measurements:
Where:
NL = Group refractivity of visible and near infrared waves in ambient moist air. Valid for atmospheric conditions described by t, p and e
nL = Corresponding group refractive index
NG = Group refractivity index for standard conditions (visible light in dry air at 0 C, 1013.25 hPa, partial water vapour pressure = 0 and the air contains 0.0375 % CO2). See Equation 4.7.
t = Dry bulb temperature of air (C).
p = Atmospheric pressure in hectopascals
e = Partial water vapour pressure (hPa)
Where:
λ = carrier wavelength in micrometres (μm) in a vacuum These closed formulae (Eq. 4.6 and 4.7) deviate less than 0.25 ppm from the accurate formulae between -30 C and +45 C, at 1000 hPa pressure, 100% relative humidity (without condensation) and for wavelengths between 650 nm and 850 nm. The 1.0 ppm stated in recommendation 3 of resolution 3 makes some allowance for anomalous refractivity and the uncertainty in the determination of the atmospheric parameters.
Recommendation 2 and 3 have been applied in the Medjil software where atmospheric corrections have not been applied to the uploaded EDM observation data. The formulae for recommendation 2 are used for calibrating a baseline. The formulae for recommendation 3 are used for calibrating EDM Instrumentation.
All certified distances on a calibrated baseline are on the same horizontal plane at a specified reference height and on the same vertical plane running through the first and last pillars.
The geometric corrections contain four components:
Pillar coordinates and elevation are required and used to determine the baseline location to derive geometric correction of the distances. Medjil computes an average value of the supplied coordinates.
Where:
dR = Certified horizontal distance between two pillars reduced to a reference elevation HREF
H1 = Elevation of EDM instrument pillar + HEDM
H2 = Elevation of reflector pillar + HREF
HEDM = Height of EDM instrument above pillar
HREF = Height of reflector above pillar
dO= Mean observed distance between EDM instrument and reflector as corrected for atmospheric effects
ΔH = H1 – H2
HREF = Reference Elevation
O1 =Offset at pillar 1 from the straight line between the first and last pillars
O2 = Offset at pillar 2 from the straight line between the first and last pillars
R =Mean radius of curvature of the Earth at the baseline location.
To convert a certified horizontal distance between two pillars to a slope distance between the tops of these pillars the following equations is used:
Where:
dR = Certified horizontal distance between two pillars reduced to a reference elevation HREF
dX = Slope distance between the tops of two pillars
H1 = Elevation of EDM instrument pillar + HEDM
H2 = Elevation of reflector pillar + HREF
HEDM = Height of EDM instrument above pillar
HREF = Height of reflector above pillar
dO= Mean observed distance between EDM instrument and reflector as corrected for atmospheric effects
ΔH = H1 – H2
HREF = Reference Elevation
O1 = Offset at pillar 1 from the straight line between the first and last pillars
O2 = Offset at pillar 2 from the straight line between the first and last pillars
R = Mean radius of curvature of the Earth at the baseline location.
The geometric correction equations 4.8 and 4.9 were derived from The Australian Geodetic Datum Technical Manual, National Mapping Council of Australia, Special Publication 10 and are suitable for baselines with steep gradients.
Medjil uses the GRS80 spheroid for determining the mean radius of the earth (R) used in the calculation of the geometric correction. Medjil requires UTM coordinates to be specified for all EDMI calibration pillars. These coordinates are used along with the following formula to determine R for each geometric correction (GDA2020 technical manual pp. 47).
Where:
p = Radius of curvature of the spheroid in meridian
v = Radius of curvature of the spheroid in prime vertical
a = Semi-major axis of the spheroid
f = Flattening of the spheroid
Q = Latitude of the baseline location
Medjil uses the following terminology:
Medjil adheres to the recommendation outlined in ISO 17123-4:2012, Section 6.5. It allows the definition of an uncertainty budget by combining individual sources of uncertainty (Type A and Type B) to derive combined standard uncertainty and expanded uncertainty as a representative measure of accuracy.
The combined standard uncertainty CSU of a number of individual uncertainty sources (ui) is computed using the following formula:
The combined expanded uncertainty CEU is defined as follows:
Where:
k = coverage factor
veff = effective degrees of freedom
Where:
vi = degrees of freedom of an uncertainty source (i)
t = t-student distribution (probability, effective degrees of freedom)
An uncertainty budget consists of a table of uncertainty sources that contribute to the combined uncertainty. Medjil provides a default uncertainty budget but also permits the creation of 'Custom' (company-specific) uncertainty budgets that can be select during the calibration process.
The uncertainty budget is composed of the follwing types of uncertianty budget sources:
The Medjil ‘Default’ uncertainty budget has all options in the 'Instrument Register Record - Uncertainty Budget Sources' and 'Derived - Uncertainty Budget Sources' selected. It also defines six 'Custom - Uncertainty Budget Sources' that are appropriate for typical calibrations.
When creating a Custom uncertainty budget, Medjil will use the Default as a template to initiate the creation of the new uncertainty budget.
Where:
Name = Custom uncertainty budget name. Uncertainty budgets are identified by a name that must be unique.
Company = The owner of the new uncertainty budget. The new budget(s) are accessible to any user within that company.
Std Dev Used When Statistically Zero = This value is used to overruled (overwrite) any standard deviation equal to zero. For example Medjil uses the sample standard deviation of observation sets composed of measurements between the same pillars to calculate an uncertainty of the EDMI measurements. When all measurements in the one observation set are the same or if there is only one measurement in the observation set, the sample standard deviation is mathematically zero.
Type = Definition of uncertainty type. Type A means a statistically derived component or uncertainty where Type B stands for any other derivation of uncertainty e.g. calibration report, manufacturer's specification or an estimate based on experience.
Distribution = Definition of distribution associated with the uncertainty. A normal distribution is most associated with continuous univariate distributions such as many random variables. A rectangular distribution represents an arbitrary outcome that lies between certain bound (equal probability anywhere within the range). For example rounding of a physical quantity or a resolution of digital instrument.
Uncertainty = The expanded uncertainty at 95% confidence in the units specified for the uncertainty source.
K = The coverage factor is used to expand the uncertainty from 68% confidence level to 95% confidence level. Typically k=2.0 for a normal distribution or sqrt(3) for a rectangular distribution. Medjil will auto complete this field as the distribution drop-down is changed but the user still has the ability to overwrite this field.
Dof = Degrees of freedom. For a Type A uncertainty this is equal to the number of measurements minus the number of unknowns (redundant measurements). For a Type B uncertainty Dof needs to be estimated. The following can be used as a guide: 3 for not very confident, 10 for moderate confidence, 30 for very confident.
Group = Uncertainty sources are categorised into 11 different groups. The group selected for an uncertainty source will affect the following:
EDM scale factor = Uncertainty related to the EDM scale factor can be specified in parts per million (ppm), percent (%), scalar(x:1) or a ratio (1:x). All error sources belonging to this group will be combined before the contribution to the total uncertainty of the calibration according to the following formula:
Where:
sud = Standard uncertainty of the distance
D = Distance
csug = Combined standard uncertainty of the group
The 'Default' Uncertainty Budget lists an error source with the description 'EDM scale factor affected by Temp (Type B)'. The EDM scale factor can be affected by temperature. This uncertainty component is a Type B estimate based on prior knowledge and experience.
EDMI measurement = Uncertainty relating to the EDMI measurement can be specified in metres (m), millimetres (mm), parts per million (ppm), percent (%), scalar(x:1) or a ratio (1:x). All error sources belonging to this group will be combined before the contribution to the total uncertainty of the calibration according to the following formula:
Where:
sud = Standard uncertainty of the distance
csug = Combined standard uncertainty of the group
EDM LS zero offset = Uncertainty relating to the EDM Least Squares zero offset can be specified in metres (m) or millimetres (mm). All error sources belonging to this group will be combined before the contribution to the total uncertainty of the calibration according to the following formula 4.13
Temperature = Uncertainty related to the temperature can be specified in degrees Celsius (°C) or degrees Fahrenheit (°F). All error sources belonging to this group will be combined before the contribution to the total uncertainty of the calibration according to the following formula:
Where:
sud = Standard uncertainty of the distance
D = Distance
csug = Combined standard uncertainty of the group
K = Partial differential for temperature defined as:
Where:
p = Pressure [hPa]
t = Temperature [C]
nG = Manufacturers reference refractive index
e = Partial water vapour Pressure [hPa] defined as:
Where:
E = Saturation water vapour [hPa] at the dry bulb temperature
h = Relative humidity [%]
Pressure = Uncertainty related to the pressure can be specified in millibars (mBar), hectopascals (hPa) or millimetres of mercury (mmHg). All error sources belonging to this group will be combined before the contribution to the total uncertainty of the calibration according to the following formula:
Where:
sud = Standard uncertainty of the distance
D = Distance
csug = Combined standard uncertainty of the group
L = Partial differential for Pressure defined as:
Humidity = Uncertainty relating to the humidity must be specified as a percent (%). All error sources belonging to this group will be combined before the contribution to the total uncertainty of the calibration according to the following formula:
Where:
sud = Standard uncertainty of the distance
D = Distance
csug = Combined standard uncertainty of the group
M = Partial differential for humidity defined as:
Certified distances = Uncertainty relating to the certified distances can be specified in metres (m), millimetres (mm), parts per million (ppm), percent (%), scalar(x:1) or a ratio (1:x). All error sources belonging to this group will be combined before the contribution to the total uncertainty of the calibration according to the following formula:
Where:
sud = Standard uncertainty of the distance
csug = Combined standard uncertainty of the group
EDMI calibration = Uncertainty relating to the EDMI calibration can be specified in metres (m) or millimetres (mm). All error sources belonging to this group will be combined before the contribution to the total uncertainty of the calibration according to the Eg. 5.21.
Centring = Uncertainty relating to the centring can be specified in metres (m) or millimetres (mm). All error sources belonging to this group will be combined before the contribution to the total uncertainty of the calibration according to the Eg. 5.21.
Heights = Uncertainty relating to the heights can be specified in metres (m) or millimetres (mm). All error sources belonging to this group will be combined before the contribution to the total uncertainty of the calibration according to the following formula:
Where:
sud = Standard uncertainty of the distance
D = Distance
csug = Combined standard uncertainty of the group
∆H = Height difference between the from and to pillars
Offsets = Uncertainty relating to the offsets can be specified in metres (m) or millimetres (mm). All error sources belonging to this group will be combined before the contribution to the total uncertainty of the calibration according to the following formula:
Where:
sud = Standard uncertainty of the distance
D = Distance
csug = Combined standard uncertainty of the group
∆O = Difference in offset between from and to pillars
If the 'Default' uncertianty budget is used, Medjil automatically populates uncertainty sources shown in Table 5.1 and Table 5.2 when processing the calibration of EDM Baselines and EDM Instrumentation respectively. Except for the following, these uncertainty sources are optional when using a custom uncertainty budget:
The automatically populated uncertainty sources are defined as follows:
Where:
ucΔH = Expanded uncertainty of the height difference between pillar i and pillar j
uco = Expanded uncertainty of the offset between pillar i and pillar j
Hi = Tabulated experimental standard deviation of the ‘From Pillar’
Hj = Tabulated experimental standard deviation of the ‘To Pillar’
k = t(95%,30)
Where:
uco = Expanded uncertainty of the offset between pillar i and pillar j
oi = Tabulated experimental standard deviation of the ‘From Pillar’
oj = Tabulated experimental standard deviation of the ‘To Pillar’
k = t(95%,30)
This uncertainty source is assigned 30 degrees of freedom and the coverage factor is the t-student at 95% and 30 degrees of freedom t(95%,30)
Where:
Q2 = The secondary CoFactorMatrix
Q = The CoFactorMatrix from the LSA of calibrating a baseline
A2 = A design matrix for every possible combination of from and to pillars
The standard uncertainties of all inter-pillar distances are equivalent to the square root of the diagonals of the secondary CoFactorMatrix. These values are stored for each baseline calibration. The inter-pillar distance standard uncertainties that correspond to EDMI calibrations are used to calculate the ‘Uncertainty of Certified Distances’ according to the formula:
ucij = k * Sij
Where:
ucij = Expanded uncertainty of a distance between pillar i and pillar j
k = Coverage factor of a baseline calibration determined by the t-student at 95% and LSA derived degree of freedom (dof) t(95%,dof)
Sij = Standard uncertainty of a distance between pillar i and pillar j
(a) if the calibration of the EDMI has tested for cyclic errors and found them to be significant:
Where:
SIC = Standard uncertainty of the Instrument Correction
D = Distance
Szpc = Standard uncertainty of the Zero Point Correction (m)
Sscf = Standard uncertainty of the Scale Correction Factor (1:x)
U = Instrument Unit Length (m)
S1 = Standard uncertainty of the term 1 - Cyclic (1:x)
S2 = Standard uncertainty of the term 2 - Cyclic (1:x)
S3 = Standard uncertainty of the term 3 - Cyclic (1:x)
S4 = Standard uncertainty of the term 4 - Cyclic (1:x)
(b) if the calibration of the EDMI has not tested for cyclic errors, has found them to be insignificant:
The uncertainty is calculated according to the following formula:
Where:
uIC = Expanded uncertainty of the Instrument Correction
k = Coverage factor determined by the t-student at 95% and LSA derived degree of freedom (dof) t(95%,dof)
Table 5.3 An example set of EDMI measurements observed on a EDM Baseline
Pillars | Raw Distances (m) | Average Distance | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
From | To | Slope Dist. 1 | Slope Dist. 2 | Slope Dist. 3 | Slope Dist. 4 | Slope Dist. 5 | Slope Dist. (m) | Dist. Std (mm) |
1 | 2 | 20.4005 | 20.4005 | 20.4006 | 20.4004 | 20.40050 | 0.07 | |
1 | 3 | 122.3877 | 122.3875 | 122.3875 | 122.3876 | 122.38758 | 0.08 | |
1 | 4 | 305.9899 | 305.9899 | 305.9900 | 305.9900 | 305.98995 | 0.05 | |
1 | 5 | 448.7901 | 448.7901 | 448.7901 | 448.7902 | 448.79013 | 0.04 | |
1 | 6 | 509.9729 | 509.9728 | 509.9728 | 509.9729 | 509.97285 | 0.05 | |
2 | 1 | 20.4009 | 20.4011 | 20.4009 | 20.4009 | 20.40095 | 0.09 | |
2 | 3 | 101.9871 | 101.9870 | 101.9869 | 101.9870 | 101.98700 | 0.07 | |
2 | 4 | 285.5891 | 285.5891 | 285.5888 | 285.5889 | 285.58898 | 0.13 | |
2 | 5 | 428.3894 | 428.3892 | 428.3893 | 428.3892 | 428.38928 | 0.08 | |
2 | 6 | 489.5733 | 489.5730 | 489.5732 | 489.5733 | 489.5730 | 489.57316 | 0.14 |
3 | 1 | 122.3877 | 122.3877 | 122.3877 | 122.3878 | 122.38772 | 0.04 | |
3 | 2 | 101.9872 | 101.9870 | 101.9870 | 101.9870 | 101.98705 | 0.09 | |
3 | 4 | 183.6028 | 183.6027 | 183.6027 | 183.6027 | 183.60273 | 0.04 | |
3 | 5 | 326.4033 | 326.4034 | 326.4034 | 326.4034 | 326.40338 | 0.04 | |
3 | 6 | 387.5854 | 387.5858 | 387.5856 | 387.5854 | 387.5855 | 387.58554 | 0.15 |
4 | 1 | 305.9901 | 305.9902 | 305.9902 | 305.9903 | 305.99020 | 0.07 | |
4 | 2 | 285.5894 | 285.5894 | 285.5897 | 285.5895 | 285.5896 | 285.58952 | 0.12 |
4 | 3 | 183.6025 | 183.6027 | 183.6026 | 183.6028 | 183.6028 | 183.60268 | 0.12 |
4 | 5 | 142.8025 | 142.8026 | 142.8024 | 142.8024 | 142.80248 | 0.08 | |
4 | 6 | 203.9846 | 203.9846 | 203.9845 | 203.9846 | 203.98458 | 0.04 | |
5 | 1 | 448.7904 | 448.7904 | 448.7904 | 448.7904 | 448.79040 | 0.00 | |
5 | 2 | 428.3904 | 428.3903 | 428.3903 | 428.3904 | 428.39035 | 0.05 | |
5 | 3 | 326.4035 | 326.4035 | 326.4035 | 326.4034 | 326.40348 | 0.04 | |
5 | 4 | 142.8027 | 142.8027 | 142.8027 | 142.8028 | 142.80272 | 0.04 | |
5 | 6 | 61.1820 | 61.1819 | 61.1822 | 61.1824 | 61.1823 | 61.18216 | 0.19 |
6 | 1 | 509.9726 | 509.9727 | 509.9728 | 509.9727 | 509.97270 | 0.07 | |
6 | 2 | 489.5721 | 489.5720 | 489.5722 | 489.5724 | 489.5720 | 489.57214 | 0.15 |
6 | 3 | 387.5860 | 387.5863 | 387.5865 | 387.5862 | 387.5862 | 387.58624 | 0.16 |
6 | 4 | 203.9853 | 203.9851 | 203.9852 | 203.9851 | 203.98518 | 0.08 | |
6 | 5 | 61.1825 | 61.1827 | 61.1827 | 61.1827 | 61.18265 | 0.09 |
Table 5.4 An example set of alignment survey
Surveyed From Pillar | To Pillar | Offset (m) | Average (m) | Standard Deviation (m) |
---|---|---|---|---|
2
3 4 5 6 1 |
1 |
0.000
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 |
0.000 | 0.001 |
1
3 4 5 6 2 |
2 |
0.112
0.112 0.111 0.113 0.113 0.112 |
0.112 | 0.001 |
1
2 4 5 6 3 |
3 |
0.116
0.117 0.117 0.116 0.117 0.116 |
0.116 | 0.000 |
1
2 3 5 6 4 |
4 |
0.132
0.131 0.131 0.131 0.132 0.132 |
0.131 | 0.001 |
1
2 3 4 6 5 |
5 |
0.151
0.150 0.150 0.151 0.150 0.150 |
0.150 | 0.001 |
1
2 3 4 5 6 |
6 |
0.000
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 |
0.000 | 0.001 |
In matrix notation:
Residuals:
Where:
A = The design matrix
x = The vector of observations
y = The vector of the unknown output estimates
r = The vector of residuals
The least square adjustment solution:
Where:
P = The weight matrix
Please note detailed description of the least squares adjustment method is out of scope of this manual. This method is widely used in surveying, geodesy and photogrammetry to solve overdetermined systems of equations based on the principle of minimising the sum of observation's residuals squares. User can explore this method in numerous available publications eg. "Practical Least Squares Adjustment of Surveying Measurements” by Alan R. Dragoo or “Adjustment Computations” by Charles D. Ghilani.
Table 7.1 provides a lists of the ISO 17123-4:2012 recommended hypothesis testing to help with the interpretation of the calibration results.
Test | Null hypothesis | Alternative hypothesis |
---|---|---|
A | s ≤ σ | s > σ |
B | s = ε̃ | s ≠ ε̃ |
C | δ = σ | δ ≠ σ |
The following tests assume a confidence level of 1 − α = 0.95 (95%) and a number of degrees of freedom (ν) based on number of redundant measurements.
This null hypothesis states that the calculated experimental standard deviation, s, is smaller than or equal to the manufacturers specifications value σ.
The null hypothesis is not rejected if the following condition is fulfilled:
Otherwise, the null hypothesis is rejected.
The null hypothesis states that the experimental standard deviation, s belong to the same population as the standard deviation (ε̃) obtained in the previous calibrations using the same instrumentation.
The null hypothesis is not rejected if the following condition is fulfilled:
Otherwise, the null hypothesis is rejected.
The null hypothesis states that the zero-point correction, δ, is equal to zero as supplied by the manufacturer (δ = 0)? Or, if prisms with a given zero-point correction, δ0 are used, is δ = δ0?
The null hypothesis is not rejected if the following condition is fulfilled:
Otherwise, the null hypothesis is rejected.
The calibration reports displays a set of predefined endnotes. These notes can be specified for both EDMI and Baseline calibration reports and may be either mandatory or company's specific:
To assess the baseline calibration outcome in accordance with ISO 17025:2017, it is imperative to conduct an interlaboratory comparison. Therefore, the calibrated EDM baseline needs to be compared onto other EDM baseline/s (reference laboratory) to assess if it deliver the same results. The results can be assessed using the En value ('Error normalised'):
Where:
xlab = corrected distance of the calibrated baseline
xref = corrected distance of the reference baseline
Ulab = uncertainty of the distance at the ccalibrated baseline
Uref = uncertainty of the distance at the reference baseline
If the |En| ≤ 1 the results are satisfactory meaning the calibrated baseline (laboratory) is comparable to the referance baseline (laboratory) in terms of its performance. If the |En| > 1 the results are unsatisfactory (baselines are not providing the same results).
Copyright © 2020-2024 Western Australian Land Information Authority
Last updated: 12 June 2024